The Garden Community for Garden Lovers
 

Leicestershire, United Kingdom Gb

Does anyone use pond planting socks in preference to the rigid pond baskets.
The shelf on my little pond is quite narrow and even the small baskets tend to topple off. I was thinking of making socks out of weed suppressant fabric (as I have some spare).
Apart from the the size issue, i thought the sock might keep roots in order a bit better - I have a freeloader (possibly a marigold that was hidden in a pot of Japanese iris) the roots of which are just spreading everywhere.
I had also thought of hessian if the weed fabric didn't work (but that means a trek into town on a saturday to find a shop that sells hessian)

pic below of the problem plant. it came in the soil of a pot of Japanese clematis flowered iris which is struggling while this has appeared from nothing in 5 weeks. the top growth is one thing but the roots grow incredibly quickly as well.



Img_1855

Answers

 

I think you mite be better tying your baskets together to stop them toppling off or get some strong fishing line and staking them descretly from the pond to the soil outside even if you make these socks . you will find most water plants don't even need soil to prosper .

24 Sep, 2014

 

Thanks Nosey - tying them together would just mean that they would all fall off the shelf. The biggest reason(s)- apart from them falling over - is that the rigid pots are letting the roots invade the pond and the pots look wrong just big chunks of plastic, sticking out of the water.

It's only a little pond and I thought a sock would be a little more aesthetic than the pots.

24 Sep, 2014

 

trouble is pond plants are always very vigouress because there getting all the water and food they need . you cant do a lot really as the water has to get in so the roots can get out .

24 Sep, 2014

 

sounds a bit weird but try fishnet stockings/tights as the casing. A 'friend' used them but I'm not sure if its because his missus found them in his car! The plants have grown well and they are still married.....

24 Sep, 2014

 

very good seaburn lol . I think the root mite just come threw them if you know what I mean ha ha

24 Sep, 2014

 

You can use the netted bags that oranges or other fruits or vegetables are sold in at the grocery. Just cut them to size and tie up with an electrical tie or twisty.

25 Sep, 2014

 

it wasn't me snoop. don't like fish nets!

25 Sep, 2014

 

Thanks all - I had heard about using tights/stockings so might try that option though I would think fishnets would be too loose a mesh and would let the roots escape. (Not saying whether I have fishnets available!!!!)

25 Sep, 2014

 

lol ofcourse not id get a high denier and green if you can and the roots wont come threw so easy . id still peg them with fishing line so they don't fall off .

25 Sep, 2014

 

Nothing wrong with letting the roots escape. If you have fish in the pond they love to nibble on them and fry love to hide in them. This is a water plant not a patio plant.

25 Sep, 2014

 

I agree boggy but everyone too there own .

25 Sep, 2014

 

And to that NP I agree too.

25 Sep, 2014

 

cool

25 Sep, 2014

 

No fish - I don't want roots clogging up the waterfall motor. Will experiment this weekend.

25 Sep, 2014

 

im wondering what plants you have . perhaps a photo will help .

25 Sep, 2014

 

pic added

26 Sep, 2014

 

looks like water cress its great as a natural filter and for fry but you don't have fish . its good because of the roots . taste a little bit of leaf and it should be peppery if im right . it will root from any joint on the plant . in the garden it would be a nightmare . id repot and get rid of it if you don't like it .

26 Sep, 2014

 

NP is right. It is watercress and it is a very fast grower not suitable for medium to small ponds. Makes a great sandwich though.

26 Sep, 2014

 

Thanks for that. I've decided that it's coming out tomorrow! My pond is way too small for it.

27 Sep, 2014

 

no problemo mate

27 Sep, 2014

 

You can buy bags for pond plants which are made for just your problem and they come in several sizes.
I tried them as my shelf has a bit of a slope and baskets tend to move till they fall off. The ones I used were Velda Pond Planting Bags small medium and large I think.

29 Sep, 2014

 

Thanks Drc - I saw the velda bags and thought they were a bit pricey for what they were. I improvised at the weekend - one made from old tights and one from weed fabric - not sure how effective they will be but my pond water is now looking very muddy. May have to think again if the water doesn't clear.

1 Oct, 2014

How do I say thanks?

Answer question

 


Not found an answer?