The Garden Community for Garden Lovers

Sick rose


By Bernard

Cambridgeshire, United Kingdom Gb

I'm sending a picture of one of the new flowers on our favourite rose that is looking very unwell. It has been kept watered, fed and treated with Rose Clear, there are no signs of pests and I have absolutely no idea what the poor thing is suffering from. Can anyone offer me a diagnosis please?

On plant Rosa




Looks like balling and browning from rain to me, although I can see some black objects on the bud next to the opened flower - I can't tell what they are though. If the rose is otherwise healthy in the leaves, as you say, then that's all it is. Remove the flower.

10 Jul, 2009


I have a lovely pink rose that does exactly the same thing when it's been raining. I just snip away the disfigured bloom and wait for the new buds to open in the sunshine. If the rain has been particularly heavy the buds will ball and brown without ever opening, but it does no harm to the bush. I just snip those away too.

10 Jul, 2009


Does this happen with other plants, too, such as Dianthus? Sometimes the flowers on my Dianthus seem to rot, and other times they rot before the buds even open. So is it likely to be rain?

10 Jul, 2009


Could be, I guess, though it might also be some kind of mildew affecting the plant. Rain definitely affects Pelargonium geraniums - the flower heads look awful after a lot of rain. And even worse is if the sun comes out and its hot after rain.

10 Jul, 2009


Sometimes the damaged petals harden and become paper-like, then the flower can't open. Best to cut them off and wait for new buds to form.

10 Jul, 2009


Thanks folks for your helpful and reassuring replies. The damaged roses have duly been snipped. Bamboo, the objects you spotted on the bud turned out on closer inspection to be greenfly, so they also are gone!!

11 Jul, 2009

How do I say thanks?

Answer question

Related photos

  • Paul's scarlet rambler in full bloom (Rosa filipes (Rambler rose))
  • Rosa 'Caribbean Dawn' (Rosa)
  • Rambler Paul's Scarlet (Rosa filipes (Rambler rose))
  • Rose at Regents Park (Rosa)

Related products


Related questions

Not found an answer?