The Garden Community for Garden Lovers

United Kingdom Gb

what is the best soil treatment for root veg? Thanks for your replies. Should I assume therefore that phosphates and potash are good additives for subteranean growth (root veg) and nitrogen (or ?) additives good for foliage and fruiting growth (i.e. lettuce, brassica, tomato, sweetcorn etc.et al?




Answers

 

Hi Roy and welcome to GoY. Depends on the root to be honest. Potatoes like a good humus rich soil and my SO usually creates a trench which he fills with compost or well rotted manure. Carrots and parsnips like a fine sandy soil with not compost and no stones. Onions and other root veg. like some compost but are not the greedy feeders that, for example, brassicas are.

21 May, 2012

 

Umm Snoopy brassicas are not root veggies which Roy is specifically asking about!

21 May, 2012

 

What's an SO Moongrower?

21 May, 2012

 

Significant Other

21 May, 2012

 

Since when has a potato been a root crop? Thought it was an underground stem. Since when has onion been a root crop?

The turnip, which is a brassica, is classified as a root crop.
Beets, carrots, parsnips, radishes, turnips are the recognised root crops.

As to preparation, plenty of phosphates and potash for carrots, very little nitrogen as that can lead to cracks.

21 May, 2012

 

Scrumpy in the growing system I follow both potatoes and onions are viewed as root vegetables in terms of the way they are grown.

22 May, 2012

 

Well the original question was on root vegetables, not on how to grow potatoes and onions which aren't, no matter what growing system you use, even though i don't agree with your onion advice, or brassicas as you pointed out to snoopy, even though the brassica turnip is a root vegetable.
To answer the original question again, phosphates and potash are the essentials for roots and for fruiting, but more importantly as you say is the type of soil.

22 May, 2012

 

Peace, peace, folks! Sticking my oar in, potatoes are certainly a subterranean crop whether they are roots or not!

Thanks for the SO, Moongrower. That's the third abbreviation I've learned on here - SO, OH and OMG (which is Not oh my god in this context...)

23 May, 2012

 

Not all root crops are subterranean, so that doesn't make sense.

23 May, 2012

 

Snoopdog, I have no argument with you... and yes we can all add to the picture. I often think my ways are out-of-date - snag is we've all been growing for a very long time

24 May, 2012

 

Scrumpygrat you've intrigued me now - which veg roots don't grow under the ground? I only meant that potatoes do, even it they aren't roots.

24 May, 2012

 

Beetroot, turnips, radishes....

24 May, 2012

 

Can't argue with that!

25 May, 2012

How do I say thanks?

Answer question

 


Not found an answer?