The Garden Community for Garden Lovers
 

United Kingdom Gb

I having a Gardening disagreement with my Wife,She says our runner beans should flower as they grow,I said they establish themselves on the canes first, then flower and grow.Who's right please?




Answers

 

Your wife, obviously and as usual!!!!!!!

4 Jul, 2010

 

The wife, always, even when she is wrong! Which is of course never.

4 Jul, 2010

 

I ave flowers and they are not any where near the top of the canes yet. and I am a wife but this is what my hubby taught me. They keep growing even when you are ipcking the beans

4 Jul, 2010

 

This 'wife' says they flower as they grow! And Bulba has already said I am always right :-) lol!!

4 Jul, 2010

 

good one mg :o)

4 Jul, 2010

 

lol!

4 Jul, 2010

 

I would hate to disagree with a woman but I'm going to anyway! Lol
Runners do need to establish themselves first, growing about 4 - 5 feet before flowering. They will continue to grow after flowering but if yours haven't flowered yet don't worry about it for a couple more weeks.
Once the fruit starts growing, the more you pick the more they will produce until the end of the season.

4 Jul, 2010

 

Brave man.
Cannot say about runner beans, hate the dratted things so we never grow them. However Climbing French beans do grow without flowers for a while, then begin producing.

5 Jul, 2010

 

Sorry Ian i think you're wrong mine are flowering from the bottom as they grow.ps i'm a lady lol. :0))

5 Jul, 2010

 

He! He! I'm keeping out of this one LOL

5 Jul, 2010

 

First of all I have my better halfs permission to say this.
Plants flower for one reason and one reason only, to produce seed. The production of a flower is actually quite an energy expensive thing to do, hence why some plants flower once and die (Century plant say, many others). So a plant of any description is not going to have the energy to produce a flower until it has grown for a while. The only time a plant produces a flower very early in its life is when it considers itself to be at risk of death. That is why some usually tall weeds will flower at a few inches high in Autumn, they are setting seed as quickly as possible before winter.
So Runner bean plants are not going to begin producing flowers until they are strong enough, and as important to them, not until the plant reaches a height at which its flowers become visible to pollenating insects.
Draw your own conclusion as to when a Runner bean plant starts flowering.

5 Jul, 2010

 

Now Tulsa, don't you start on me!
Just because I'm only a man doesn't mean I can't be right sometimes. Carol says I can be right but only when she says so! Lol

I'm not saying runner beans don't flower from the bottom but as Owdboggy agree's they need to be well established before they will do.

Sprinkler1 do you see the can of worms you have opened? Lol :~))

5 Jul, 2010

 

Worms... oh the birds will love you Sprinkler!

5 Jul, 2010

 

Ian will you ever learn,my beans are doing very well thank you with flowers starting at the bottom. What does Carol say on the subject ?come to think of it i wonder if sprinkler is any wiser ? lmso.

5 Jul, 2010

 

Sprinkler is very conspicuous by his absence don't you think? I bet he's laughing HIS socks off as well. Lol

Carol understands as much about growing veg as I do about quantum physics! She allows me to "play" in the garden, as long as I don't go out through the gate on my own!

5 Jul, 2010

 

LOL Ian you behave and don't dare go through that gate ! Sprinkler and his wife are still very quiet after opening this can of worms,For the last time the lady is right, ok. xxx

5 Jul, 2010

 

Sorry for not responding earlier but I was enjoying the comments,I started to photograph my runner beans this morning,so I can edit when(or if) they flower.Thanks for all the replys so far(think my Wifes ahead at the moment)lol

5 Jul, 2010

 

check out photograph dated 5/7/2010

6 Jul, 2010

 

I'm right, I'm right! Lol

A lovely looking plant there Sprinkler, growing well but without any flowers YET! Lol

I might not be allowed out on my own but I do know my veggies! ! ! ! ! ! ! ! Lol ;~)))))

6 Jul, 2010

 

Behave Ian :0))

6 Jul, 2010

 

Lol Tulsa, :~)))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))))

6 Jul, 2010

 

I looked to day and i've got 2 beans whoope.

6 Jul, 2010

 

Right I'm coming round your place at midnight and you won't have in the morning! Lol

6 Jul, 2010

 

I'm scared you know where i live as well. 2 won't make much of a meal though 1 for Carol 1 for you.:0)))))))))))

6 Jul, 2010

 

Lol. :~))

6 Jul, 2010

 

Sorry Holly i'l save you a carrot.:0))))))))))

7 Jul, 2010

 

LMSO Tulsa, I'm still right, you can't get round me like that or are you trying to get my ladies on side? Lol

7 Jul, 2010

 

Okay I'm going to shock you all... I was WRONG! One of our runner beans is now 2 metres tall and has yet to produce a flower, none of the others has yet either. They d ohowever flower from the bottom up - lol

7 Jul, 2010

 

Lol MG :~))

7 Jul, 2010

 

That will teach me to say the woman is always right :-) :-) Frankly none of us is always right!

7 Jul, 2010

 

Except us men of course! Lol .......... Lol ;~))

7 Jul, 2010

 

Err that would be a big NO!

7 Jul, 2010

 

LMSO, it's a good job we all know and trust each other! It could turn quite nasty else Lol

7 Jul, 2010

 

my lips are sealed LOL:0))

8 Jul, 2010

How do I say thanks?

Answer question

 


Not found an answer?