The Garden Community for Garden Lovers

Will bulbs grow up through shale ?

Hampshire, United Kingdom Gb

I have various bulbs planted in a long wooden trough, it is topped with shale will they come through or do I need to remove the shale




Answers

 

they will come up through loose lightweight shale no problem ,

22 Mar, 2009

 

you beat me to it macc part of a bulbs life cycle is to disapear below the frost line and push up through soil,shale,gravel etc

22 Mar, 2009

 

No problem at all. I have seen bulbs push quite heavy stones aside. We have bulbs growing in the gravel paths.

22 Mar, 2009

 

The shale may contain arsenic, which is a total weedkiller.

22 Mar, 2009

 

id go with the doc on this one macc i didnt know that thanx for that.hope your fealing better

22 Mar, 2009

 

doc do you mean some types of shale contain arsenic or alternatively do you mean an arsenic based weedkiller may have been applied to the trough?

22 Mar, 2009

 

good question macc beat me to it lol

22 Mar, 2009

 

In my experience I have had it damage shrubs planted in it, shale is for speedway tracks. Even worse, arsenic gravel mined in the Tamar valley used as a base for gravel drives. Neither hogging scalpings etc. are a good growing structure. I have burnt my hands using arsenic as a weedkiller.
Recently we had a question on old tarmac put on the flowerbeds, which is a similar thing.

22 Mar, 2009

 

I remember the tarmac in flower beds question , tarmac is also carconegenic , maybe Suzilufc will come back to us with a further description of the "shale"in question, it certainly could be dangerous if it contains arsenic.

22 Mar, 2009

 

I suspect that there is 'shale' and then there is 'shale'. I have never heard of this arsenic problem before and we have plenty of shale up here that supports a vibrant plant community.
By the toxic shale are you talking about coal mine slag heap shales?

22 Mar, 2009

 

carconegenic ?

22 Mar, 2009

 

Shale in Scotland is a natural formation of rotten rock, in many parts of the south it is used for speedway tracks and also as a base for roadways and pathways etc. The amount of arsenic as with other toxic chemicals is so small that it is not harmful to humans and animals, but with plant life it can deform or discolour and even kill. This is a very interesting subject. I hope Suzilufc won't get too worried about it.

23 Mar, 2009

 

very interesting.is the arsnenic already in it ? if not why is it in it doc ?

23 Mar, 2009

 

The arsenic may be in it, or it may be introduced by man, or it will be in there naturally from the ground. Some shale will be arsenic free.

23 Mar, 2009

 

ow thanx for that doc hope ya fealing better mate

23 Mar, 2009

 

np carconegenic just means that whatever chemical or substance is deemed as carconegenic then to some degree or another given correct circumstances could cause cancers , tarmac being oil based has the potential for this in certain states. eg tobacco has carconegenic properties

23 Mar, 2009

 

Doc I think by now between us we have probably put most people off shale and tarmac lol

23 Mar, 2009

 

thats handy to know thanx macc

23 Mar, 2009

 

np np

23 Mar, 2009

 

cool

23 Mar, 2009

How do I say thanks?

Answer question

 


Not found an answer?