The Garden Community for Garden Lovers

Berwickshire, United Kingdom Gb

Identify from poor picture please

A journalist was asking me about giant hogweed and mentioned she'd had an 'invader' in the garden and she had skin trouble the day after removing it.

It's a rather poor image but I wonder if anyone knows it. Zoom in and you can see the stems are 'hairy'.

I've had this second picture which isn't much better. It could be Symphytum but without a better picture of the flowers it's hard to say. As the plants are no more, no better picture is possible.



Kay_s_plant_2_0002crop

Answers

 

It looks a bit like Borage, that has hairy stems and leaves and does hurt your hands.

19 Aug, 2011

 

Thanks, that looks quite likely.

19 Aug, 2011

 

By the way we can't zoom in on a photo

19 Aug, 2011

 

Moon_grower

Hit ctrl and + together and your browser will magnify the page. Do it as many times as you like.

19 Aug, 2011

 

I thought it looked like borage too, Thepoisongardener, but it's a bit difficult to tell without seeing the flowers, as they are very striking and vivid blue.

Thanks for that tip, by the way, about zooming. My OH knew it of course! He'd never told me. Annie

19 Aug, 2011

 

I think its more likely one of the Symphytums, in other words, Comfrey. The leaves on that are horrid to touch and can irritate.

19 Aug, 2011

 

To zoom in you can also use the zoom level on the bottom right hand corner of the web page (where it says 100% or whatever you have it set to) and you can enlarge picture up to 400%!!!

19 Aug, 2011

 

Don't have a display like that, Sheilar - I just use Zoom under View to restore after doing Control ++.

19 Aug, 2011

 

Ah yes you can zoom in that way but all it does is make a fuzzy photo larger... There are sites where you can click on a small image and instantly a large image pops up much easier to view because they are clearer. Don't think it is comfrey leaves are broader but zoom or no a fuzzy photo is a fuzzy photo.

19 Aug, 2011

 

Could be Symphytum uplandicum though. But you're right, the pic's fuzzy.

19 Aug, 2011

 

What's the connection with giant hogweed though? Did you think this might be it? The giant hogweed is 7 or 8 feet high, hence the name!

19 Aug, 2011

 

Steragram

As I said, this was a journo asking me about giant hogweed (which grows more like 12-15ft) and this plant came up as a 'by the way...'

I was trying to explain why I only had a poor picture.

19 Aug, 2011

 

Well we all know it isn't giant hog weed as to what it is without a better photo, which apparently you can't take, we are basically playing a guessing game.

19 Aug, 2011

 

Sorry, must be a bit thick this evening...

19 Aug, 2011

 

Nope this particular Q seems to have gone round in circles Steragram so not thick! I'm still not sure why Giant Hogweed appears in the Q when it is obvious that this isn't... TPG's answer to our Q's actually left me more confused! A simple 'what is this and is it a skin irritant would have worked' and I'm sure that not all my Q's are clear :-)

19 Aug, 2011

 

This poor person was just asking a simple question!! It only needed a simple answer too.
Hi TPG. I too think it might have been borage which my daughter has and yes it does sting when you touch it, in fact it is quite a vicious plant, we only grow it for the very pretty flowers which can be used a decoration on home made cake.

19 Aug, 2011

 

Just for the record, all I was doing was trying to explain that I had only a distant relationship with the person who had this plant in the hope of avoiding the 'can you get a better photo?' questions.

Thanks Grandmage. I'm inclined towards borage too since I've never heard of anyone having skin problems from Symphytum. Still, if it is one of the two, it's nothing too serious.

20 Aug, 2011

 

Well you have now, Poisongardener - I can't touch the comfrey in the garden downstairs, it irritates in exactly the same way as borage does for me, but its not a strong reaction to either, more just itchy prickling irritation.

20 Aug, 2011

 

Thanks, Bamboo, sorry to hear that.

20 Aug, 2011

 

Not a big deal really - as far as I'm concerned, if it feels unpleasant to touch, there's a reason for that, and a remedy - wear gloves, lol!

20 Aug, 2011

How do I say thanks?

Answer question

 


Not found an answer?