The Garden Community for Garden Lovers

Can anyone please tell me what the difference is between 'Daylight electric bulbs' and Grow lights ?

Worcester, United Kingdom Gb

I have fixed up two energy saving daylight bulbs inside a coil warmed frame,hoping to germinate seeds a bit earlier than usual. ( indoors and a bit dark ).I have since seen 'Grow lights' advertized and I am wondering if they are the same thing ,or if perhaps the ordinary bulbs will not help at all. I was hoping for stronger young seedlings.




Answers

 

Hi Vera. The following is part of a paper produced by a friend of mine and put in the public domain. I hope it helps and if you want the entire document I could PM it to you. As you can see you really need a light box.

Research has been done on the Internet. This has revealed that there are special grow lamps and systems available. But these can be expensive, are not always available in this country, and are not necessary. Ordinary fluorescent lights will do just as well for the average user.

'Light levels

The key element of a light box is to get enough light for the plants. Light levels are measured in lux. Examples are: -

0.25 Full moon on a clear night
10 Candle at a distance of a foot
50 Family living room lights
400 Brightly lit office
1,000 TV studio lighting
20,000 Sunny day

For plants, an adequate level is usually taken to be about 2000 lux. This can be achieved if the plant receives about 20 watts per square foot of fluorescent tube light. However a 20 watt light over a one square foot area will not achieve this, as most of the light will be lost and only a small percentage will fall on the target area.

This is where the concept of a light box comes in. To prevent light being lost, the plants and the lights must be enclosed in a box that reflects all the light from the source onto the plants. A good light box can be as efficient as 75% or even higher. Ie, 75% of the light produced will fall on the plants. It could be as low as 5% without a box.

To achieve high efficiency, the walls of the box must be highly reflective, and the box must be totally enclosed allowing nothing to escape. The most efficient reflectors are mirrors and metalised melinar film, but a good white surface is nearly as good. In practice 100% efficiency will never be obtained so it is advisable to put the lights as close to the plants as possible. This can be achieved by attaching the lights to a suspended ceiling, which can be raised or lowered. Normal practice is to have the light two inches from the top of the plants. There are systems that allow the lights to be a lot further away, but the lights must be much more powerful and hence wasteful. That sort of system is more useful for large plants, where the light can’t be two inches away from every part of the plant.

Light sources

There is much talk about special bulbs with the correct spectrum for growing plants. in practice the light from any sort of bulb is adequate for most purposes. However the bulb should be as efficient as possible, partly to save money and partly to reduce the heat given out, which could scorch the plants. Bulb efficiency is measured in lumens of light per watt, and typical values are: -

Ordinary light bulb (incandescent) 15
Quartz halogen 24
LED (Light Emitting Diode) 25 – 50
Long life (fluorescent) light bulbs 55
Long fluorescent tubes 70
Sodium street lights (yellow ones) 150

The best practical light source is a long fluorescent tube. Long life light bulbs, which are small coiled fluorescent tubes are not quite as efficient. Tubes are inefficient at the ends, so the longer tube the better. They are also said to deteriorate faster with time than straight tubes. Long tubes also produce more even lighting. The fastest developing type of light source is the LED and it is predicted it will eventually be as efficient as sodium lamps – but it is not there yet.

One popular misconception is that more efficient bulbs produce less heat. That is not true. No common bulb turns more than 10% of the electricity used into light, so the other 90%+ is turned into heat. A 100 watt incandescent light bulb seems hotter than a 100% watt fluorescent tube only because its smaller and the heat is less spread out. But they both give out virtually the same amount of heat – 100 watts,'

It really isn't as complex as it looks at first sight.

John.

12 Feb, 2009

 

ordinary light bulbs and fluorescent tubes tend to give out light in the yellow area of the spectrum. for 'optimum' growth plants use the blue end and red for flower initiation. so you need to check if the daylight bulbs emit the correct wavelengths of light. after all plants are green because they dont absorb it and as yellow is next to green it isnt much use. wattage of 60+ will be adequate.

I have found light levels at this time of year fine. sometime ago i saw a suggestion of lining the back of the propagator with aluminium foil as it will reflect all the natural light back and prevent bending to the light. This has worked for me. also once germinated i have turned the heat down a bit.
hope it helps.

12 Feb, 2009

 

'after all plants are green because they dont absorb it'

And I thought it was all about chlorophyll. I'll tell Professor Sutcliffe that his paper is all wrong. Lol.

John.

13 Feb, 2009

 

plants are green coz chlorophyll doesnt absorb the green wavelength, it is reflected. sorry tired when i posted comment but many people dont even understand about light or how we 'see' in colour. over simplification and all that. photosynthetic pigments are more complex than just one pigment; as any a-level biology student will atest to.

sorry if i offended. lol

13 Feb, 2009

 

Thank you, John, that was an excellent answer to the question about plant lighting.

10 Apr, 2016

How do I say thanks?

Answer question

 


Related questions

Not found an answer?