Gardening Questions Unknown Shrub part 2

Close-up_leaves
spritzhenry

Unknown Shrub part 2

Asked by Spritzhenry on 6 Mar, 2008

I took more photos of the shrub - I'd love to know what it is! Here's the leaves closer-up. There's another picture of the back of the leaves close-up on my page.

Answer question

Replies

Sid

Sid

6 Mar, 2008

 

Right. Another bite of the cherry. I now think it's an Eleagnus, which is what I was thinking of before! (I had a eureka moment in the bath). I'm not completely sure, but the glossy evergreen leaves and the silvery reverse points to Eleagnus. My book mentions wavey leaf margins, but not toothed leaves. The mystery deepens.......

spritzhenry

Spritzhenry

6 Mar, 2008

 

I haven't got a picture to compare it with yet- I shall google it - but I do think that's a possibility! E x ebbingei in my Hillier doesn't have the serrated edges to the leaves, but one of the others might. Later - well, I can't find it - but that doesn't mean it's not. SIGH. Keep trying, guys, please!

Buzzbee

Buzzbee

6 Mar, 2008

 

For what it's worth, I found reference to 2 Eleagnus - E. umbellata - a semi evergreen the leaves are described by Anita Periere as "have wavy edges and silvery undersides." The other she refers to is E. pungens, which she describes as a spiny shrub. Might be red-herrings but maybe further routes to investigate.

spritzhenry

Spritzhenry

6 Mar, 2008

 

See above - I did try them all via google. Mine is most definitely completely evergreen. Also, it's not spiky. There's a picture of E.umbellata in Hillier - no, it's not that one! No luck as yet!

bluespruce

Bluespruce

6 Mar, 2008

 

Try Osmanthus x fortunei

spritzhenry

Spritzhenry

6 Mar, 2008

 

Looked at picture in Hillier - not much like it, sorry. Good thinking.

majeekahead

Majeekahead

7 Mar, 2008

 

defo not E.pungens, can rule that one out for you spritz - i have one of these and completely different! will have a look through some of my dutch books for ya.

majeekahead

Majeekahead

7 Mar, 2008

 

how about Ardidia crispa - does your plant flower and have fruit? cos these do, not sure about the underside of the leaf and my pic does'nt show or mention this but the top side looks very simular! there is also another variety that sounds like a possiblilty A. japonica - but i don't have a pic.

majeekahead

Majeekahead

7 Mar, 2008

 

another to try would be Azara several spec, with toothed hairless dark green leaves, again i think most do flower, and no pic, or mention of underside of leaf, but might be another avenue to try.

jacque

Jacque

7 Mar, 2008

 

Hi Barbara
Iv just taken a PIC of a SHRUB i have in apot in my garden It looks just like the 1 your trying2name?But its wet from the rain.What do you THINK is it this ?

spritzhenry

Spritzhenry

7 Mar, 2008

 

No Jacque, yours is much spikier and glossier and a deeper green. Thanks for trying! majeeka, I shall check your suggestions out.

AndrewR

Andrewr

7 Mar, 2008

 

You could also check some of the brachyglottis spritz (they used to be senecios). I have B.munroi which looks a bit similar

spritzhenry

Spritzhenry

7 Mar, 2008

 

Yes, but only a bit, I'm afraid, Andrew! I might have to cut a bit off and send it to the RHS I think. It really is a mystery, this one. Now if it were to flower, that would help, wouldn't it! I shall be keeping my beady eye on it each month!

spritzhenry

Spritzhenry

7 Mar, 2008

 

Hi majeeka - have checked both of your suggestions, no luck I'm afraid. Any other thoughts?

majeekahead

Majeekahead

8 Mar, 2008

 

no fraid not apart from my A-Z which i know you have yourself, i only have my dutch ident books (which are a little bit out of date anyway), and i have given you everything remotely like it from there - where did you get it from? if a garden centre or nursary maybe they would know? sorry i can't be of more help, good luck with finding it - please let us know if you do get to the bottom of it.

spritzhenry

Spritzhenry

8 Mar, 2008

 

I inherited it! It was here in the garden (hidden at the back of an inaccessible border) until the Ceanothus died and I was able to scramble up the wall and literally crawl under the Weeping Pear to the back fence - and there it was! I almost wish I hadn't found it, 'cos it's driving me mad!

AndrewR

Andrewr

8 Mar, 2008

 

How about an olearia (daisy bush)?

Lori

Lori

9 Mar, 2008

 

Not to be impertinent, but maybe it is some kind of nut tree.

spritzhenry

Spritzhenry

9 Mar, 2008

 

I will check out the Olearia - don't think it's a nut tree,Lori, no signs of dropped nuts or shells under or round or on it.

bluespruce

Bluespruce

9 Mar, 2008

 

Andrew may be on the right track, I'll now go for Olearia macradonta.

spritzhenry

Spritzhenry

11 Mar, 2008

 

Although it has yet to flower to be sure, I think I agree with Bluespruce and Andrew - in the RHS photo the leaves do look VERY like those on my mystery shrub - Bit scary to read that it grows to 20' x 15' though! Thank you all, guys, for your research. I knew I could count on you to ID it! Nice if it does flower, now that I've cleared the border a bit it has more light so watch this space! :-)

Answer question