Gardening Questions Are these caterpillar eggs?
Are these caterpillar eggs?
Asked on 5 Jul, 2008
I found a caterpillar on a cabbage yesterday - after it had made a mess of it :o( When I looked inside my cabbage there were lots of little balls (eggs?). I've tried to get a decent photo and was hoping someone might know what they are. Thanks in advance.
Replies
5 Jul, 2008
Thanks Wyeboy. The little blighters. I'm off out there now. They're actually nestled inside the cup of the leaves.
5 Jul, 2008
Errr - ummm - caterpillars don't lay eggs, it's the butterflies that do that ;-) (I don't quite think you meant that, Wyeboy, did you? It just sounded funny!) Watch out Peter - you are in for an invasion! Get them off your cabbages before the hatch - or no cabbages. And kindly watch your language!
5 Jul, 2008
Sorry Spritz - language adjusted :o) You know I even thought caterpillar eggs sounded wrong when I wrote the question.
I think (hope) that I got them all off, although they were right down in between the leaves so I had to poke them out with a twig. Then zen calm that the snail received the other day was all worn out and they met a grizzly demise (although the eggs are so soft it would be very difficult not to squash them).
5 Jul, 2008
Not called the cabbage white butterfly for nothing!Munch bunch.
6 Jul, 2008
Are you sure they're eggs. I thought butterfly eggs were yellow. Maybe what you have here are caterpillar droppings. Whatever, either way you have caterpillars somewhere!
6 Jul, 2008
Hi Joannie, I'm not sure at all. Are caterpillar droppings green and crumbly? I found quite a big caterpillar on this lettuce the same day I found the 'eggs'. Hmmm - what have I been crushing without mercy!?
6 Jul, 2008
What you are seeing, Peter is excrement! No they are not eggs, as Joannie says they are a different size and colour. I have no doubt it's poop! The source is the catterpillar...LOL...thanks for the smile!!
7 Jul, 2008
Yes , how stupid of me I mean't butterfly eggs but looking again at the picture I think Lori is right it is caterpillar droppings but the way the plant is eaten I don't think it is a cabbage white, something bigger I fear!!!!By the amount eaten you would have found a good colony of cabbage white caterpillars.
7 Jul, 2008
Thanks (I think) for the update. The caterpillar was about an inch and a half long, apparently suffering from diarrhoea. No more leaves eaten since.
4 Aug, 2008
Yes i think they are indeed butterfly eggs cause if u go to this link the eggs actually turn from yellow to the colour you've described.....
http://www.milkweedcafe.com/hatchingegg.htm




Joined 9 Feb, 2007
Herefordshire
5 Jul, 2008
They would be more than likely caterpillar eggs especially if the are clustered on the underside of the leaves.